An 18-Year-Old Cosmetics Brand's Adobe Platform Collapse
A quarter of Adobe's revenue comes from its marketing and commerce business, not Photoshop.
BusinessAn 18-year-old cosmetics company is weighing whether to shut its doors
Reader, there’s a cosmetics company in Melbourne, Australia called Adorn Cosmetics. It’s a natural makeup and skincare brand that cuts down on packaging waste through refillable containers, and founder Briony Kennedy built it by putting herself front and center as the face of the brand. According to a report Australia’s 7NEWS published on November 8 (Korea time), the company — which 7NEWS described as a $6 million business — collapsed after migrating its website to Adobe’s e-commerce platform, and Kennedy now faces bankruptcy. Adobe declined to comment, citing legal reasons.
My first reaction when I saw this story was, “How could this even happen?” Right behind that came another question: how many people in Korea reading this article even know that Adobe sells an e-commerce platform at all?
In Korea, Adobe is mostly known as the company behind Photoshop, Illustrator, and Premiere Pro — a company for designers and video editors. But Adobe is also a well-established name in marketing tools, commerce, and consulting. The Adorn incident happened right in that lesser-known corner of the business.
Today I want to cover two stories together: the side of Adobe’s business that’s less known in Korea, and the Adorn case that unfolded right at the center of it. One thing I should flag up front: the Adorn dispute has only just reached the stage of a legal battle, and most of what’s public right now is Kennedy’s side of the story.
A Quarter of the Photoshop Maker’s Revenue Comes From Marketers
Looking at Adobe’s fiscal year 2025 annual report (year ending November 28, 2025), out of total revenue of $23.77 billion, the Digital Experience segment accounted for $5.86 billion, or roughly 25%. The Digital Media segment—home to Photoshop and Acrobat—brought in $17.65 billion, or 74%, with the remainder coming from advertising and publishing. Subscription revenue alone within Digital Experience reached $5.41 billion, up 11% from a year earlier.
The collective name for what this segment sells is Adobe Experience Cloud. It’s the suite of tools companies use to gather customer data, run websites and apps, launch campaigns, measure results, and sell products. The bundle launched under its current name in March 2017.
This business was built mostly through acquisitions.
| Year | Company Acquired | Amount | Current Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Omniture | ~$1.8 billion | Web analytics (the root of Adobe Analytics) |
| 2018 | Magento | $1.68 billion | E-commerce (Adobe Commerce) |
| 2018 | Marketo | ~$4.75 billion | B2B marketing automation |
| 2020 | Workfront | $1.5 billion | Marketing work management |
These four deals alone add up to over $9.7 billion. When Adobe announced its Magento acquisition in 2018, it described itself as the only company leading in content creation, marketing, advertising, analytics, and now commerce, all at once. The pitch: buy from a single company the entire flow where an image made in Photoshop goes up on a website, visitor data from that site gets analyzed, that data drives ads and emails, and the process ends in a completed purchase.
There’s another notable detail in the numbers. In fiscal 2025, the gross margin1 was 95% for Digital Media but only 72% for Digital Experience. Design tools, once built, cost almost nothing to replicate, but a business that ingests and runs enterprise customer data, hosts websites, and puts people on the ground to help with implementation carries a far heavier cost structure.
And starting in fiscal 2026, Adobe shifted the center of gravity in its earnings reporting from business segments to customer groups. One of these is named “Creative & Marketing Professionals”—bundling designers and marketers into a single customer group. In the third quarter ending August 28, 2026, this group’s subscription revenue reached $4.65 billion, up 13% year over year. The second-quarter 10-Q cited Creative Cloud alongside Adobe Experience Platform (AEP) and Adobe Experience Manager (AEM) as growth drivers for this group. Adobe itself, in other words, already sees design and marketing as one continuous business.
What Adobe Does Itself, and What It Leaves to Partners
Consulting occupies a slightly unusual spot in this business. Adobe’s annual report states that its global professional services team designs and builds solutions for its largest customers. The broader market is left to the partner ecosystem. Through its Solution Partner Program2, Adobe helps system integrators, agencies, and regional partners build out their capacity to implement Adobe technology.
The revenue Adobe earns directly from consulting isn’t large. “Services and other” revenue—which covers project-based consulting, training, and the like—came to $540 million in fiscal year 2025, roughly 2% of total revenue. Looking just at Q3 of fiscal year 2026, revenue from this line was $111 million against a cost of $125 million. Cumulative through the first three quarters, it was $334 million in revenue against $367 million in cost. This line also bundles in training, maintenance for on-premise licenses, and advertising products alongside consulting, so you can’t treat it as consulting’s P&L in isolation. Still, taken on its own, this isn’t a profitable line of business. The money is made on subscriptions; consulting exists mainly to make sure that subscription actually takes root inside the customer’s organization.
This division of labor isn’t unique to Adobe. Enterprise software companies generally sell the license, leave the actual implementation to certified partners, and hand operations over to the customer. For big customers, the software company assigns its own team directly; smaller customers get routed to partners. With this structure in mind, let’s turn to the story of Adorn.
What Happened to Adorn
Here’s the timeline as far as public records show.
- Since launching in 2009, Adorn grew its open-source3 D2C4 online sales using the open-source version of Magento. Magento is the very platform Adobe acquired in 2018. Adorn effectively started on the free version, then moved up to the paid enterprise edition within the same product family.
- In July 2020, Convert Digital, a Melbourne e-commerce agency, earned Magento Gold tier status in Adobe’s Solution Partner Program. Adobe’s partner sales lead at the time called the agency one of Adobe’s most strategic go-to-market and implementation partners.
- Around 2021, Kennedy said on an e-commerce podcast that bugs on the free version of Magento kept piling up, and when something broke, tracing where in the code it came from felt like finding a needle in a haystack. That, she said, is why she decided about a year earlier that it was time to make a real investment.
- On September 29, 2021, Adorn’s new website went live on Adobe Commerce. The announcement materials touted ingredient and origin search, real-time personalized recommendations, inventory system integration, and a loyalty program that even covered packaging returns. Kennedy said the switch would let her focus on making good products, and an Adobe Asia-Pacific executive said Adorn was realizing its ambitious e-commerce vision.
What came after is laid out in posts Kennedy has recently written on LinkedIn. According to Kennedy, Adorn in 2021 was running fine on the free open-source platform, and she had no plans to rebuild the website. All she wanted was to keep growing customer data as secure as possible. But, she says, Adobe approached her first, telling her its enterprise platform would take Adorn further while “costing less overall.” Kennedy also says it was Adobe that recommended Convert Digital as the implementation partner.
Kennedy later wrote that the losses and debt accumulated from her experience with Adobe and Convert Digital left her facing the decision of whether to shut down a company she’d poured 17 years into. She also said mediation5 ended without a settlement, and that her legal representatives have begun litigation proceedings. Right now, the homepage of Adorn’s website carries the line “Save our Australian business,” alongside a note that plenty of stock remains in hand.
A few things are worth flagging here. In the 2021 podcast, Adorn describes itself as the one who decided to invest; now, the story is that Adobe approached first. The two accounts don’t quite line up. Both could be true — Adorn may have felt the platform needed work, while the decision to rebuild the entire site from scratch could still have started with Adobe’s proposal. And exactly what broke after the migration, what the contract specified, and what Convert Digital’s position is — none of that is confirmed in the public records I found. These are the points likely to be contested in court.
Same Magento, So Why Did Things Get So Much Bigger
On the surface, this looks like an upgrade within the same family — moving from free Magento to Adobe Commerce, software built on the same root. But from the buyer’s side, it’s not just the software that changes. The whole shape of the contract changes.
When you use free open-source software, the relationship is between Adorn and a developer. Move to an enterprise platform, and there are three parties involved: Adobe, which sells the license; the partner, which builds the site; and Adorn, which has to sell products on that site every single day. As we saw earlier, Adobe only assigns its own team directly to its biggest customers. A company the size of Adorn gets a partner instead. If Kennedy’s account is right, in this case the proposal came from the platform company, the build came from a partner the platform company recommended, and the outcome landed on the customer.
What goes wrong when this structure breaks down can be laid out in general terms — separately from what actually went wrong at Adorn.
- The website is the store. For a company that sells only online, with no physical storefront, having payments, inventory, and membership data all wobble at once is the same as shutting the doors.
- Search traffic can take a hit. When you migrate a site, URLs change, and if redirects aren’t properly wired, search rankings built up over years can collapse all at once. The link rot story I covered in Issue No. 215 turns directly into a revenue problem for an online store.
- The shape of your costs changes. On top of what used to be free software, license fees and agency service fees stack up as fixed costs. Even the moment revenue dips, those fixed costs stay exactly where they are.
- Responsibility gets scattered. When something goes wrong, the platform company tends to point at the build, and the build company tends to point at the platform. In the meantime, it’s the customer who pays the cost first.
Oswarld’s Lens
In Korea, Adobe is still, first and foremost, a design-tool company. But a quarter of Adobe’s revenue comes from enterprise marketing and commerce, and Adobe itself groups designers and marketers into a single customer segment. That gap was the first thing I thought of when I looked at the Adorn case.
That gap can be a real risk for Korean companies too. If you think of Adobe as nothing more than “the Photoshop company,” you’re liable to misjudge the weight of a sales pitch that says “a partner Adobe recommends.” A partner recommendation from an enterprise software company is both a quality signal and part of its sales machinery. How far the platform company is actually on the hook when a recommended partner causes a problem is written in the contract, not in the letter of recommendation.
I always say that not everyone, and not every task, needs superintelligence — there’s a model suited to the job and the environment at hand. The same logic applies to platforms. Going by Kennedy’s account, Adorn was a company that ran perfectly well on free open-source tools. That an enterprise platform can do a lot is a different question from whether this particular company needed that much. If someone told you it would be “cheaper overall,” you needed to redo the math — not just licensing fees, but implementation costs, operating costs, and the revenue you’d lose during the transition period.
Closing
Adobe is a Photoshop company, but a quarter of its revenue comes from enterprise marketing and commerce. The Adorn affair happened on that less visible side of the business. Who did what wrong is now a matter for the courts to sort out. But even before that’s settled, there’s something any company bringing in an enterprise platform can check for itself: who’s selling it, who’s building it, and who’s accountable when things go wrong.
💬 Have you ever used an Adobe product at work beyond Photoshop or Acrobat? If so, drop a line in the comments about which one.
📨 If you know a founder who’s about to migrate e-commerce platforms or overhaul a website, send this their way.
References & Further Reading
Primary sources
- 7NEWS Australia, “Cosmetics empire crumbles after Adobe website disaster”, YouTube, 11/7/2026 (local time). ··· This is where today’s story starts. Adorn’s brush with bankruptcy and Adobe’s refusal to comment are both in the video description.
- Adobe, “Form 10-K, Fiscal Year 2025”, SEC, 2026. ··· This is where the segment revenue, gross margin, and the definitions of Professional Services and “Services and Other” revenue come from.
- Adobe, “Adobe Reports Record Q3 Results”, Business Wire, 9/10/2026. ··· This contains fiscal Q3 2026 revenue, subscription revenue by customer segment, and services revenue and cost of services.
- Adobe, “Form 10-Q, Quarter ended May 29, 2026”, SEC, 2026. ··· This is the passage that names AEP and AEM as growth drivers for the Creative & Marketing Professionals customer segment.
- B&T, “Adorn Cosmetics Gets A Digital Makeover Using Adobe Commerce”, 9/29/2021. ··· This covers the announcement around the 2021 migration, including comments from Kennedy and an Adobe APAC executive.
- B&T, “Convert Digital awarded Adobe’s Magento Gold status”, 7/3/2020. ··· This describes the tier Convert Digital earned in Adobe’s Solution Partner Program and Adobe’s assessment of the agency.
- Add To Cart, “More Chips in the Packet: The Adorn Cosmetics Story”. ··· This is the podcast where Kennedy explains, in her own words, why she decided to switch platforms around 2021.
- Briony Kennedy, LinkedIn profile and recent posts, 2026. ··· Kennedy’s own account of Adobe’s pitch, the Convert Digital recommendation, the breakdown of mediation, and the filing of the lawsuit.
Background
- Adobe, “Adobe to Acquire Magento Commerce”, 5/21/2018. ··· The announcement of the Magento acquisition.
- Adobe, “Adobe to Acquire Marketo”, SEC 8-K, 9/20/2018. ··· The announcement of the Marketo acquisition.
- Adobe · Omniture, “Adobe to Acquire Omniture”, SEC, 9/15/2009. ··· The acquisition that marked Adobe’s first major move into marketing.
- Adobe, “Adobe to Acquire Workfront”, 11/9/2020. ··· The acquisition that added marketing work-management tools to Experience Cloud.
- SiliconANGLE, “Adobe buys Magento for $1.68B to add e-commerce support to its Experience Cloud”, 5/21/2018. ··· This covers when Experience Cloud launched and how the industry reacted to the Magento acquisition at the time.
Past issues worth reading alongside this one
- Issue #52, “Adobe Paid $75 Million to Settle Dark-Pattern Charges?” ··· The same company’s other face. Today’s story is about enterprise customers; that one was about Creative Cloud subscribers.
- Issue #215, “The URL Berners-Lee Chose Died Within Four Months” ··· On why addresses and links break when sites migrate.
📝 Glossary
Footnotes
-
Gross margin: The share of revenue left over after subtracting the direct cost of producing a product or service. The higher this ratio, the more money is left over from each additional sale. ↩
-
Solution Partner Program: A system through which a software company certifies and tiers outside firms authorized to implement its products on its behalf. Higher tiers often mean more referrals from the software company’s own sales teams. ↩
-
Open source: Software whose source code is public, so anyone can use and modify it for free. There’s no license fee, but there’s also no dedicated vendor obligated to fix things when they break. ↩
-
D2C (Direct to Consumer): A sales model in which a brand sells directly to consumers through its own website, bypassing distributors or marketplaces. Margins are better, but if the website goes down, the entire sales channel goes down with it. ↩
-
Mediation: A process in which a neutral third party helps two sides reach agreement before a case goes to trial. The mediator has no power to impose a decision, so if no agreement is reached, the matter proceeds to litigation. ↩

Your take shapes the next issue
What resonated most in this issue, or where has your experience been different?