Britain Wants Pay Listed in Every Job Ad
What happens to wages once companies are forced to post salaries in job listings?
SocietyThe UK Prime Minister Said: Write the Salary Before You Write the Law
The British government announced it would push through legislation requiring employers to disclose pay in job postings as soon as possible. Prime Minister Andy Burnham went further, asking companies not to wait for the law to pass but to start listing salaries in their postings now. His reasoning: whether you’re a young person looking for your first job or a parent supporting a family, you deserve to know what a position pays before you spend the time and effort to apply.
That said, the law hasn’t actually passed yet. The government opened a public consultation on pay discrimination and transparency on July 14 and closed it on October 27, reporting that 94% of respondents favored stronger transparency measures. What exactly must be disclosed, and what happens if companies don’t comply, remains undecided.
Britain has good reason to be in a hurry. According to the job site Adzuna, only 51% of UK job postings in September included a salary, and that share has been declining for years. Korea’s figure is even lower. Of the roughly 5.12 million job postings last year across Saramin, JobKorea, and Incruit—Korea’s major job-listing platforms—only 40.9% disclosed pay. The two figures aren’t directly comparable since they’re counted differently, but the underlying picture is the same: more than one in two job postings hides the price tag.
My first thought on reading this was that knowing what someone else earns is a double-edged sword. In a society like Korea’s, it’s practically taboo.
But the phrase “pay transparency” actually bundles together two quite different things. One is the price tag on the job posting itself—a company telling the market what it’s willing to pay for a given role. The other is knowing what the colleague sitting next to you earns. In Britain, both stories broke within a week of each other. The government took on posting disclosure; the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) took on the right to ask coworkers about their pay.
Today I’ll focus on the first: the price tag on the job posting. More countries than you might expect have started requiring it, and a fair amount of research now exists on its effects. Lining up that research side by side also reveals something interesting: the two kinds of transparency push wages in opposite directions.
Where the Price Tag Went Up First
The starting point was Colorado, in January 2021. It was the first week that online job postings were required to list expected salary. The US still has no federal law on this, so states are legislating individually, and how many have posted-range requirements depends on who’s counting. Some counts put it at 13 states as of July 1, 2026; others say 15, including Washington DC, as of October. Big states like California, New York, and Washington are on the list, and Virginia’s law took effect this July.
States without such laws followed along anyway. As the laws spread, salary ranges began showing up even in postings from states with no legal requirement, and the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that more than two-thirds of all US job postings now include pay information. One expert noted that companies weren’t about to give up on applicants from California or New York — so once the big states were in, postings everywhere else shifted along with them.
Canada is moving province by province. Prince Edward Island started in June 2022, British Columbia in November 2023, and Ontario joined on January 1 this year. Ontario’s rule is the most specific of the bunch. Companies with 25 or more employees must list an amount or range in postings, and the range can’t span more than CA$50,000 a year. Positions paying over CA$200,000 a year are exempt. If AI is used to screen or evaluate applicants, that has to be disclosed in the posting too.
The European Union adopted its Pay Transparency Directive1 in 2023. Companies must state starting pay or a range in the posting, or disclose it before the interview, and they’re barred from asking applicants about their previous salary. Member states were supposed to transpose this into national law by June 7, 2026, but only four countries — Italy, Lithuania, Malta, and Slovakia — made the deadline. Greece finished shortly after, while most others, including Germany and France, are still working on it. The Netherlands is targeting implementation in January 2027, and Sweden wants to delay and renegotiate rather than implement on schedule.
The UK, as discussed earlier, is still at the law-drafting stage. The proposal is to either list pay in the posting or, if hiring without one, disclose it in writing before the interview.
Japan is the surprising case. Under the Employment Security Act, Japan requires employers to disclose working conditions to job seekers when recruiting, and wages are on that list. A guidance document from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare gives examples like “monthly salary ¥250,000 (¥200,000 during the probationary period)” — spelling out actual figures. What Europe and North America are now building into law, Japan has long treated as a basic item to disclose at the recruitment stage.
Korea has no such rule. The Fair Hiring Procedure Act has no clause requiring wage disclosure, and the Labor Standards Act’s wage-notification requirement only kicks in once an employment contract is signed. In 2018, Korea’s Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission recommended that the Ministry of Employment and Labor make wage disclosure in job postings mandatory, but nothing came of it. Several bills to amend the Fair Hiring Procedure Act are currently pending in the National Assembly, which would require postings to list wages and their components, with fines for false entries.
| Region | Start | What postings must show | Worth noting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colorado, US | January 2021 | Expected salary/range | First US state law |
| United States overall | State-by-state rollout | Salary range | No federal law; 13–15 states depending on count |
| British Columbia, Canada | November 2023 | Expected salary/range | Bans asking about previous salary |
| Ontario, Canada | January 2026 | Amount or range | Range capped at CA$50,000; AI-screening disclosure required |
| EU | Transposition deadline June 2026 | Starting pay/range (in posting or before interview) | Only 4 countries met the deadline |
| UK | Legislation in preparation | In posting or in writing before interview | Consultation closes October 27 |
| Japan | In effect | Wage must be stated at recruitment | Under Employment Security Act enforcement rules |
| Korea | None | Amendment bills pending in National Assembly | Only 40.9% of postings include wage info |
Posting the Price Tag Raised Wages
Colorado has several years of data piled up by now. The most-cited study is a 2025 working paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), by David Arnold (UC San Diego), Simon Quach (USC), and Bledi Taska (Lightcast). They used a difference-in-differences design2, comparing states that passed the law against states that didn’t.
After the law took effect, the share of postings listing a salary jumped by 30 percentage points. In Colorado alone, that figure rose from 35% to 70% in a single year. And across all three datasets, wages rose by 1.3–3.6%.
What’s worth noticing is who actually benefited. It wasn’t just new hires — wages rose for existing employees too, and even at companies that had already been disclosing salaries beforehand. The researchers interpret this as evidence that once prices get attached to job postings, the competitive pressure between companies over hiring and holding onto people intensifies. In other words, when pricing information in the market shifts, it moves wages even for people who never directly saw that information or changed jobs.
The things people worried about didn’t show up in the data. Hiring didn’t drop, the number of postings didn’t drop, and companies didn’t offset the wage increases by raising education or experience requirements. Nor did firms try to dodge the law by listing artificially wide salary ranges.
A separate study analyzing the same Colorado law points in the same direction. Posted wages rose by about 5%, and the gender pay gap among job switchers narrowed. That said, part of the narrowing came from men’s wages falling — not everyone benefited equally.
It wasn’t without side effects, either. Early in implementation, some large companies posted remote jobs while blocking Colorado residents from applying — a workaround to avoid listing a salary at all. That tactic became harder to pull off as other large states adopted similar laws. Even so, one estimate suggests that 1 in 5 Colorado job postings still don’t comply with the law.
Same Word, “Transparency,” Opposite Effect
Let’s go back to the double-edged sword I mentioned earlier. There’s research showing wages actually fell.
This is a paper Zoe Cullen (Harvard) and Bobak Pakzad-Hurson (Brown) published in the economics journal Econometrica in 2023. Rather than looking at job postings, it analyzed U.S. state laws that protect employees’ right to discuss salaries with coworkers. The result: wages dropped by about 2%.
The reason lies in how companies do the math. When coworkers can see each other’s salaries, raising one person’s pay risks triggering renegotiation demands from everyone else. That gives companies an incentive to hold the line and not pay anyone more, which weakens individual bargaining power3. Where individual negotiation already had little room to begin with — as in unionized workplaces with collective bargaining — this effect was smaller.
Put the two studies side by side and the picture comes into focus. A price tag on a job posting is information flowing outward, toward other companies — it makes firms compete over people. A coworker’s salary is information flowing inward, within the company — it gives the firm leverage to hold its ground in negotiations with individuals. Both go by the name “transparency,” but they push in opposite directions.
That said, the line isn’t clean. A price posted externally gets read internally too. When a new listing carries a range, existing employees doing the same job inevitably measure their own salary against it. One UK employment law firm advises that if a company’s incumbent salaries haven’t kept pace with what new hires are offered, it needs to decide how to handle that gap before posting a range — not after. The price tag aimed outward ends up fueling comparisons inward.
The width of the range is its own problem. The UK’s Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) has pointed out postings with ranges spanning more than £10,000. The wider the range, the more it becomes a formality — a number posted for the sake of posting — while the actual information it conveys shrinks. Ontario has gone so far as to write a cap on range width directly into its regulations.
Why Korea Still Says “Per Company Policy”
The job seekers’ answer is clear. When Jinhaksa Catch surveyed 1,180 job seekers this past August and September, 80% said they supported making wage disclosure in job postings mandatory. Half said they’d given up applying for a job because the salary wasn’t listed, while only 12% said they’d ever asked a company directly about pay. As for disclosure format, an exact figure (45%) was the most preferred option, followed by a minimum-maximum range (19%).
That 12% figure tells you a lot. Plenty of people apply without knowing the salary, or don’t apply at all — but almost nobody actually asks.
In a climate where asking risks marking you as “the candidate who only cares about money,” staying silent is cheaper than speaking up.
There’s a counterargument too. A review report from a National Assembly standing committee concluded that the law could help job seekers make more rational choices and narrow pay gaps by gender and employment type — but it also flagged limitations. Since pay varies by experience and expertise, setting standards in advance is difficult; the administrative burden on small and mid-sized businesses is heavy; and if companies disclose only an overly wide range, the policy loses its effectiveness. Minister of Employment and Labor Younghoon Kim raised concerns about corporate trade secrets and instead proposed providing standardized wage information by industry — the Ministry plans to disclose median wages and the top/bottom 25% levels by sector.
But industry-wide wage distributions and a job posting’s price tag are two different things. An industry average tells you roughly what the market pays, not what this specific role you’re applying for pays. A Ministry official explained that the two issues are related but ultimately separate policies.
Oswarld’s Lens
At first, I was told that knowing what someone else earns is a double-edged sword — and that in Korea, it’s treated as something close to taboo.
Following the research, though, the edge of that blade comes into sharper focus. A price tag on a job posting creates competition with the world outside the company; a coworker’s salary reshapes negotiations inside it. What Korea treats as taboo is mostly the inside version — your deskmate’s paycheck. I don’t see much reason to lump in writing a number on a job posting with that same taboo.
The phrase “per company policy” deserves a second look too. If there’s a policy, that means the number already exists somewhere. Leaving it off the posting looks less like preserving room to negotiate and more like an effort to keep the applicant pool from shrinking.
If disclosure became mandatory, the first to feel the pinch would be small and mid-sized firms whose listings would sit right next to big-company postings, numbers exposed side by side. Whether to read that as the market finally finding its true price, or as something that deepens the labor shortage, is likely to be the real fault line in Korea’s debate. In that light, it’s worth noting that the National Assembly’s amendment requires disclosing not just the total wage figure but also its component items and the basis for calculating them. At companies where performance bonuses make up a large share of pay, looking at base salary alone tells you very little about what you’ll actually take home.
Closing
The rule requiring salary disclosure in job postings started in Colorado, spread across North America and the EU, and now the UK is heading down the same path. Japan already requires wages to be disclosed at the recruiting stage. Research on pay transparency has, so far, mostly pointed to one conclusion: wages go up. The question left for Korea seems less about whether to disclose and more about how narrowly the range gets drawn — and what gets left out.
💬 Reader, have you ever given up on applying for a job because the posting didn’t list a salary? Tell me in the comments what wording was in that posting.
📨 Pass this piece along to an HR colleague writing job postings, or to a coworker weighing a job change.
References & Further Reading
Primary sources
- BBC, “Firms told to publish salaries in job adverts ahead of new law”, 2026.11. ··· Prime Minister Burnham’s remarks, the 94% approval rate among consultation respondents, Adzuna’s 51% figure, and CIPD’s point about overly wide pay bands all come from this article.
- David Arnold, Simon Quach & Bledi Taska, “The Impact of Pay Transparency in Job Postings on the Labor Market”, NBER Working Paper 34480, 2025. Link ··· This study analyzes the laws of multiple states following Colorado’s, using three different datasets. Its key finding: even incumbent employees’ pay rose.
- Zoë B. Cullen & Bobak Pakzad-Hurson, “Equilibrium Effects of Pay Transparency”, Econometrica 91(3), 2023. Link ··· This paper finds that laws protecting coworkers’ right to discuss pay with each other lowered wages by about 2%. Read alongside the job-posting studies, it fills out the full picture.
- Feng, an analysis of the wage and gender-gap effects of Colorado’s pay transparency law, IZA conference paper, 2023. Link ··· This analysis finds roughly a 5% rise in posted wages, and notes that part of the narrowing gender gap came from falling wages for men.
- European Commission, “New EU rules on pay transparency explained”, 2026.6.5. Link ··· An official one-page explainer on the rights the EU directive grants to applicants and employees.
- Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (Japan), “Working conditions that must now be disclosed at recruitment,” 2024. Link ··· A list of the working conditions Japanese employers must disclose when recruiting, including pay-related items and sample disclosures.
- Hankyung (The Korea Economic Daily), article on the debate over mandatory pay disclosure in job postings (reporter Daeyoung Kim), 2026.9.18. Link ··· Brings together the Jinhaksa Catch survey, the National Assembly’s review report, and remarks from the president and the minister in one place.
- Financial News (Korea), “Pay disclosure in job postings: jobseekers’ rights vs. hiring chill… Ministry of Labor ‘recognizes the need’”, 2026.10.12. Link ··· The source of Rep. Yongwoo Lee’s office’s analysis finding that only 40.9% of about 5.12 million job postings listed pay.
Background
- Colorado Newsline, “Colorado’s pay transparency law increased wages across the board, study finds”, 2025.11.21. Link ··· Reports that Colorado’s rate of pay disclosure in postings rose from 35% to 70%, with an estimated 1 in 5 postings still non-compliant.
- Insurance Journal, “How Colorado Sparked a Global Push for Salary Transparency”, 2026.1.14. Link ··· Covers early workarounds, such as remote job postings excluding Colorado residents, and how the trend spread to states without such laws.
- Money, “Researchers Find Pay Transparency Laws Really Do Raise Wages”, 2025. Link ··· Cites a New York Fed analysis finding that more than two-thirds of job postings now include salary figures.
- CNBC, “How Colorado’s pay transparency law is impacting work in the state”, 2022.8.4. Link ··· Includes forecasts that companies won’t abandon states like California or New York over such laws.
- Teamed, “Pay transparency and job posting rules in Canada”, reviewed 2026.10. Link ··· Summarizes Ontario’s cap on pay-band width, its exemption for high earners, its AI-screening disclosure requirement, and British Columbia’s rules.
- Trusaic, “EU Pay Transparency Directive: Who Transposed, Who Delayed, the Risks”, 2026.6.17. Link ··· Tracks each member state’s progress past the deadline; this is where I confirmed the positions of the Netherlands and Sweden.
- Lewis Silkin, “UK pay transparency in recruitment: pay ranges in job adverts are under consultation”, 2026.7.16. Link ··· A law firm’s explainer on the UK consultation’s contents, also touching on the legislative debates in Korea and Mexico.
- Trethowans, “Employment Alert: UK Government Consultation on transparency in UK pay”, 2026. Link ··· Advises employers to first map out pay gaps between existing employees and new hires.
- Nocut News, “President Lee responds on ‘pay disclosure’… will job postings soon state salary?”, 2026. Link ··· Lays out the Ministry of Labor’s plan to disclose industry-wide pay distributions.
Related past issues worth reading
- Issue No. 92, “Artificial Intelligence Paid Women Less.” ··· It examines what happens when pay is set inside a black box. If today’s piece is about pulling the price tag out into the open, that piece is about what happens when the process of setting the price stays invisible.
📝 Glossary
Footnotes
-
Pay Transparency Directive (Directive (EU) 2023/970): A set of rules the EU adopted in 2023 to strengthen equal pay between men and women. An EU “directive,” by principle, obligates member states rather than companies directly — member states must transpose it into domestic law before it binds firms, which is why implementation timing varies by country. ↩
-
Difference-in-differences: An analytical method that isolates a policy’s effect by comparing the change in a group affected by the policy against a group that wasn’t. It rests on the assumption that, absent the policy, both groups would have moved along similar trends. ↩
-
Individual bargaining power: The leverage an individual worker has to negotiate a higher salary with their employer. Where pay is set through collective agreements, this leverage has little room to operate. ↩

Your take shapes the next issue
What resonated most in this issue, or where has your experience been different?